The Science Fiction, Fantasy, & Weird Fiction Magazine Index

Magazine Contents Lists: Page 738

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 1, Whole No. 13, Winter 1946-47] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 20¢, 36pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 2 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 3 · Painter in Words · Thyril L. Ladd · ar 4 · Body’s Beauty · Dante Gabriel Rossetti · pm (r) 5 · Wadleton’s Sarah Mandrake · Matthew H. Onderdonk · br [Ref. Maggie Jeanne Wadleton] 7 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi 8 · Forgotten Creators of Ghosts—VII · A. Langley Searles · ar 9 · Molnar’s Slave of Ea · John C. Nitka · br [Ref. Ferenc Molnar] 10 · The Immortal Storm [Part 6 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 20 · Tips on Tales · John C. Nitka · rc 21 · Fantasy in the Munsey Publications [Part 1 of 2] · William H. Evans · bi 35 · Merritt’s Fox Woman & Bok’s Blue Pagoda · A. Langley Searles · br [Ref. A. Merritt & Hannes Bok]

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 2, Whole No. 14, Spring 1947] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 37-74pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 38 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 39 · Half a Century of Writing · Lt. Col. David H. Keller, M.D. · ar 48 · Tips on Tales · A. Langley Searles · rc 49 · The Immortal Storm [Part 7 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 58 · Fantasy—in Top Hat! · Thyril L. Ladd · ar 59 · “In a Quaintly Shaped Skull…” · Joseph Krucher · pi 60 · “Amid a Maze of Gravestones…” · Joseph Krucher · pi 61 · Coblentz’ When the Birds Fly South · Matthew H. Onderdonk · br [Ref. Stanton A. Coblentz] 61 · Fantasy in the Munsey Publications [Part 2 of 2] · William H. Evans · bi 72 · Open House · [The Readers] · lc

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 3, Whole No. 15, Summer 1947] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 75-110pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 76 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 77 · Weinbaum’s Unpublished Novel, The Mad Brain · Sam Moskowitz · ar [Ref. Stanley G. Weinbaum] 82 · Sloane’s Edge of Running Water · Maynard Solomon · br [Ref. William Sloane] 83 · Tips on Tales · A. Langley Searles · rc 84 · Rotation for Better Crops of Fantasy · Henry Kuttner · ar 86 · The Immortal Storm [Part 8 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 97 · Stapledon’s Death Into Life · Richard Witter · br [Ref. Olaf Stapledon] 99 · Chaos · Thyril L. Ladd · ar 102 · The Birth of Art · A. Merritt · pm Bohemia 1904 103 · Todd’s Lost Traveller · John F. Burke · br [Ref. Ruthven Todd] 104 · Open House · [The Readers] · lc 105 · Forgotten Creators of Ghosts—VIII · A. Langley Searles · ar

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 4, Whole No. 16, Fall 1947] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 20¢, 111-146pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 112 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 113 · The Gothic Novel and Percy B. Shelley · James Warren Thomas · ar [Ref. Percy B. Shelley] 120 · White’s Mistress Masham’s Repose · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. T. H. White] 121 · The Tarzan Theme · Darrell C. Richardson · ar [Ref. Edgar Rice Burroughs] 123 · The Thrill Book · William H. Evans · ar 131 · Moore’s Greener Than You Think · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. Ward Moore] 132 · Faunus Nocturnal · L. Blackledge Lippmann · pm 133 · Tips on Tales · John C. Nitka · rc 134 · The Immortal Storm [Part 9 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 144 · Lytle’s Name for Evil · Matthew H. Onderdonk · br [Ref. Andrew Lytle] 146 · Open House · [The Readers] · lc

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 5, Whole No. 17, Winter 1948] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 147-182pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 148 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 149 · This Is About Ray Cummings · Thyril L. Ladd · ar [Ref. Ray Cummings] 152 · Fantasy in All-American Fiction · William H. Evans · bi 154 · Little Known Fantasy—I · Darrell C. Richardson · ar 155 · Unwritten Books · David H. Keller, M.D. · ar 157 · Stapledon’s Flames · Sam Moskowitz · br [Ref. Olaf Stapledon] 160 · A Wine of Wizardry · George Sterling · pm Cosmopolitan Magazine September 1907; illustrated by Joseph Krucher 168 · Something About Vampires · George T. Wetzel · ar 169 · Tips on Tales · A. Langley Searles · rc 171 · The Immortal Storm [Part 10 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 184 · Cabell’s There Were Two Pirates · Paul Spencer · br [Ref. James Branch Cabell]

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 6, Whole No. 18, Spring 1948] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 183-220pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 185 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 187 · John Buchan: A Possible Influence on Lovecraft · Sam Moskowitz · ar [Ref. John Buchan & H. P. Lovecraft] 190 · Clouds · H. P. Lovecraft · pm The Tryout July 1919, as by Ward Phillips 191 · “Erich Zann Was a Genius of Wild Power” · Joseph Krucher · pi 192 · Photographs of the Lovecraft-Phillips Family · [uncredited] · pt 193 · Charon—in Reverse · Matthew H. Onderdonk · ar 197 · Serviss’s Edison’s Conquest of Mars · Sam Moskowitz · br [Ref. Garrett P. Serviss] 201 · Keller’s Life Everlasting · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. David H. Keller] 203 · H.P.L. on Imaginative Fiction · Darrell C. Richardson · ar [Ref. H. P. Lovecraft] 204 · Taine’s Forbidden Garden · Richard Witter · br [Ref. John Taine] 206 · Tips on Tales · Thyril L. Ladd · rc 207 · The Immortal Storm [Part 11 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 219 · Some Lovecraft Sidelights · F. Lee Baldwin · ar [Ref. H. P. Lovecraft]

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 7, Whole No. 19, Summer 1948] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 221-258pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 222 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 223 · Music in the Wilderness · Paul Spencer · ar 227 · Karig’s Zotzl · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. Walter Karig] 228 · Occult Authenticity in Bulwer-Lytton’s Novels · James Warren Thomas · ar [Ref. Bulwer-Lytton] 234 · Did Lovecraft Miss This? · Thyril L. Ladd · ar [Ref. H. P. Lovecraft] 235 · Tips on Tales · Winston F. Dawson · rc 237 · Shadows Over Lovecraft · David H. Keller, M.D. · ar [Ref. H. P. Lovecraft] 246 · The Elder Runes · Joseph Schaumburger · pm 247 · The Immortal Storm [Part 12 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 257 · Gottlieb’s Key to the Great Gate · Raymond Van Houten · br [Ref. Hinko Gottlieb] 257 · Fantasy in Romance Magazine · William H. Evans · bi 258 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. II No. 8, Whole No. 20, Fall 1948] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 259-296pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 260 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 261 · The “Polaris” Trilogy · Richard Witter · ar [Ref. Charles B. Stilson] 264 · Tips on Tales · Thyril L. Ladd · rc 265 · An Analytical Approach to the Supernatural-Horror Tale · George T. Wetzel · ar 266 · Beyond the Shadow · Genevieve K. Stephens · pm 267 · In a Glass—Darkly · Matthew H. Onderdonk · ar 271 · Phillpotts’ Lycanthrope · Marion Zimmer · br [Ref. Eden Phillpotts] 273 · Fantasy in the Popular Magazine · William H. Evans · bi 282 · Merritt & Bok’s Black Wheel · A. Langley Searles · br [Ref. A. Merritt & Hannes Bok] 284 · The Immortal Storm [Part 13 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 290 · Talbot Mundy: Oriental Mystic · Darrell C. Richardson · ar [Ref. Talbot Mundy] 292 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi 294 · Indexes to Volume Two of Fantasy Commentator · [uncredited] · ix

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. III No. 1, Whole No. 21, Winter 1948-1949] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 32pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 2 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 3 · Conflict for the Soul · David H. Keller, M.D. · ar 11 · Two in One · Thyril L. Ladd · ar 12 · Pratt & de Camp’s Carnelian Cube · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. L. Sprague de Camp & Fletcher Pratt] 13 · Of an Old Woman · Genevieve K. Stephens · pm 14 · Leaves—a Botanical Rarity · Redd Boggs · ar; on the magazine Leaves. 19 · Mullen’s Moonfoam and Sorceries · Alice M. Perry · br [Ref. Stanley Mullen] 20 · Tips on Tales · A. Langley Searles · rc 21 · Mr. Hubbard Points the Way · George Ebey · ar 23 · Open House · [The Readers] · lc 28 · The Immortal Storm [Part 14 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. III No. 2, Whole No. 22, Spring 1949] ed. A. Langley Searles (A. Langley Searles, 25¢, 33-64pp, quarto) Details taken from Table of Contents. 34 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 35 · Encores in the Wilderness · Paul Spencer · ar 38 · A Pair of Satires: East and West · Francis T. Laney · ar 40 · Timlin’s Ship That Sailed to Mars · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. William Timlin] 42 · Little Known Fantasy—II · Darrell C. Richardson · ar 43 · Midsummer’s Eve · Joseph Schaumburger · pm 44 · Taine’s Cosmic Geoids · Richard Witter · br [Ref. John Taine] 46 · Keller’s Solitary Hunters & The Abyss · Philip Gray · br [Ref. David H. Keller] 48 · The Immortal Storm [Part 15 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 57 · Tips on Tales · John C. Nitka · rc 58 · Checklist of Avon Fantasy Reader · J. Russell Mars · bi 60 · The Sigil of Scoteia · David H. Keller, M.D. · ar [Ref. James Branch Cabell] 61 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. III No. 3, Whole No. 23, Summer-Fall 1949] 64 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed; a list of all fantasy books, with annotations, not previously mentioned in the “editorial” pages. Continues at the foot of some other pages, lists approx. 74 titles. 65 · Chaucer and Science-Fiction · Samuel Sackett · ar 67 · The Logic of the Keller Cycle · Alex Osheroff · ar 70 · The Devil’s Mistress · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. J. W. Brodie-Innes] 71 · The Man Who Came at Midnight · Ruth M. Eddy · ar [Ref. H. P. Lovecraft] 72 · The Immortal Storm [Part 16 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 82 · Behold Thy Host · Genevieve K. Stevens · pm 82 · The Madman · Thomas H. Carter · pm 83 · Some Radio Fantasy · James Harmon · ar; brief looks at “Lights Out”, “The Shadow”, “The Mysterious Traveller”, “Suspense”, “Weird Tales” and other radio series. 85 · Tips on Tales · Charles Peter Brady · rc _85 · Seen and the Unseen · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. Richard Marsh] _85 · Doings of Raffles Haw · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. A. Conan Doyle] _85 · Last Spaceship · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. Murray Leinster] 86 · Keller “Homunculus” · Thomas H. Carter · br 88 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi; an annotated listing of the fantasy fiction in “All-Story” from Jul, 1910 to Jan 23, 1915.

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. III No. 4, #24, Winter 1949/1950] ed. A. Langley Searles (25¢, 30pp) (Full Text) Details supplied by Denny Lien. 94 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed; very brief comments on some thirty recent sf/f books. 94 · Vampire · A. M. Perry · pm 95 · The Face of Fantasy: 1950 · Sam Moskowitz · ar; a survey of state of magazines, publishers, fandom, etc. 111 · Book Review: Exiles of Time, by Nelson S. Bond · Thomas H. Carter · br [Ref. Nelson S. Bond] 113 · Tips on Tales · Thyril L. Ladd · rc _113 · Gay Hunter, by J. Leslie Mitchell · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. J. Leslie Mitchell] _113 · Athalie, by Robert W. Chambers · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. Robert W. Chambers] _113 · Little Night Music, by Barbara Hunt · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. Barbara Hunt] _113 · Savaran and the Great Sand, by Douglas Newton · Thyril L. Ladd · br [Ref. Douglas Newton] 114 · A 17th Century Weird Play · Samuel Sackett · ar [Ref. Thomas Goffe]; on Goffe’s Tragedy of Orestes. 116 · The Immortal Storm [Part 17 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 121 · Book Review: Shot in the Dark, ed. Judith Merril · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. Judith Merril] 122 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi; notes on fantasy stories in All Story-Cavalier, Feb.8-July 3, 1915.

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. III No. 5, #25, Winter 1951-1952] ed. A. Langley Searles (36pp) Details taken from Table of Contents. 124 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed 125 · Space Opera · George O. Smith · ar 129 · Wright’s Throne of Saturn · Thomas H. Carter · br [Ref. S. Fowler Wright] 131 · The Ghoul-Changeling · George T. Wetzel · ar 132 · Brown’s What Made Universe · Matthew H. Onderdonk · br [Ref. Fredric Brown] 135 · Stanley G. Weinbaum: A Comprehensive Appraisal · Sam Moskowitz · ar [Ref. Stanley G. Weinbaum] 150 · The Silver Birches · A. Merritt · pm Nepenthe 1940 151 · Master of Fantasy · Darrell C. Richardson · ar; presumably on A. Merritt. 152 · Tips on Tales · John C. Nitka · rc 153 · Open House · [The Readers] · lc 157 · The Sword of Genghis Khan · Thyril L. Ladd · ar 158 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi

Fantasy Commentator [Vol. III No. 6, Whole No. 26, Spring-Summer 1952] 160 · This-’n’-That · A. Langley Searles · ed; a list of all fantasy books, with annotations, published throughout 1950 and 1951 and the early part of 1952. Covers pages 160 & 184-189 and lists approx. 220 titles. 161 · Weaver of Nightmares · George T. Wetzel · ar [Ref. Edward Lucas White]; a critical appreciation of Edward Lucas White. 167 · Little Known Fantasy—III · Darrell C. Richardson · ar; a look at fantasy fiction in “New Magazine”, “New Story” and “All Around”. 169 · New Tales of Space and Time · Charles Peter Brady · br [Ref. Raymond J. Healy] 171 · Night’s Yawning Peal · A. Langley Searles · br [Ref. August Derleth] 172 · Thumbing the Munsey Files · William H. Evans · bi; a very brief listing on this occasion, giving an annotated listing of the fantasy fiction in “All-Story” from Dec 11, 1915 to Jan 8, 1916. 173 · The Immortal Storm [Part 18 of 20] · Sam Moskowitz · ar 182 · Dream City · Thomas H. Carter · pm 183 · Tips on Tales · John C. Nitka · rc _ · Missing Angel · John C. Nitka · br [Ref. Erle Cox] _ · Bat Woman · John C. Nitka · br [Ref. Cromwell Gibbons] _ · The Last Man · John C. Nitka · br [Ref. Mary Shelley] 190 · Open House · [The Readers] · lc _ · [letter] · Darrell Richardson · lt _ · [letter] · Thomas G. L. Cockroft · lt _ · [letter] · Francis T. Laney · lt _ · [letter] · Sam Moskowitz · lt