| 
 Reprint of the July 1958 (UK) issue. Details derived from a cover scan and the contents of the UK issue. |   | 
| 
 Reprint of the August 1958 (UK) issue. Details derived from a cover scan and the contents of the UK issue. Some copies of this issue were dated “March” on the price sticker. |     | 
| 
 Issue partially indexed - probably a reprint of the September 1958 (UK) issue. | 
| 
 Reprint of the October 1958 (UK) issue. |   | 
| 
 Reprint of the November 1958 (UK) issue. |   | 
| 
 Reprint of the December 1958 (UK) issue. |   | 
| 
 A pulp magazine in all but format, Justice carried the subtitle “Amazing Detective Mysteries”, but focused on crime-adventure rather than detective puzzle plots. | 
| 
 Details supplied by John Locke. |   | 
| 
 Details taken from Table of Contents. |   | 
| 
 Details taken from Table of Contents. |   | 
| 
 Details supplied by James Felton. |   | 
| 
 Reprint magazine rebinding unsold copies of Complete Detective Novel Magazine and Wild West Stories and Complete Novel Magazine. | 
| 
 A rebinding of the November 1932 issues of Complete Detective Novel Magazine, pgs 7-142 and Wild West Stories and Complete Novel Magazine, pgs 7-142. Contents listed on the front cover; no printing on spine or back cover. Details taken from front cover. |   | 
| 
 A rebinding of the December 1932 issues of Complete Detective Novel Magazine, pgs 5-142 and Wild West Stories and Complete Novel Magazine, pgs 5-142. Contents listed on the front cover; no printing on spine or back cover. Details supplied by John Locke. |   | 
| 
 Probably a rebinding of the January 1933 issues of Complete Detective Novel Magazine, pgs 7-142, and Wild West Stories and Complete Novel Magazine, pgs 7-142. Issue not indexed. | 
| 
 A rebinding of the February 1933 issues of Complete Detective Novel Magazine, pgs 7-142, and Wild West Stories and Complete Novel Magazine, pgs 7-142. Contents listed on the front cover; name and numbering on spine; ad for Amazing Stories on back cover. Details supplied by John Locke. Issue partially indexed. | 
| 
 --- see under Detective Casebook. | 
| 
 Initially Keyhole Mystery Magazine presented a good array of the more standard mystery and detective short stories by many of the better-known mystery fiction authors, but was unable to sustain sales and folded after only three issues. It was relaunched over a year later, by a different publisher, under the title Keyhole Detective Story Magazine, with an emphasis on a more violent, fast-action, clip, heavily laced with tough and coarse characters and, above all, sex. | 
| 
 | 
| 
 Details supplied by Tom Lesser. |   |